| Quarter | Spend | Primary Revenue | Primary ROAS | All Conv Revenue | All Conv ROAS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 (Jan-Mar) | $718,805 | $1,891,456 | 2.63x | $4,943,237 | 6.88x |
| Q2 (Apr-Jun) | $773,368 | $2,421,478 | 3.13x | $9,151,587 | 11.83x |
| Q3 (Jul-Sep) | $1,077,492 | $2,444,950 | 2.27x | $9,045,792 | 8.39x |
| Q4 (Oct-Nov 8) | $404,541 | $554,736 | 1.37x | $2,761,137 | 6.82x |
| YTD Total | $2,974,205 | $7,312,619 | 2.54x | $25,901,753 | 8.71x |
4 NCAC campaigns (Shopping USA NCAC, Hair Quiz PMax NCAC, Hair Serums NCAC, Shampoo NCAC) have spent $212,189 combined but generate only 1.07x primary ROAS. Their non-NCAC counterparts run 2.39-3.06x. These campaigns are cannibalizing profitable auctions and should be first cut.
Only 8 primary conversions YTD. This awareness campaign has consumed $105K since Sep 4 with essentially zero return. Budget is better reallocated to proven PMax and Shopping campaigns.
Already paused. $65K wasted with 35 conversions. Should remain off permanently.
The 4th biggest spender is underwater on primary ROAS. Only 82 new customers all year ($1,802 NCAC). Mostly re-engaging existing customers. Needs 50-75% budget cut and tighter audience exclusions.
Generic non-brand search traffic that isn't converting profitably. Needs heavy negative keyword work or a pause while product-level non-brand campaigns are tested instead.
Branded Search (4.10x, $902K), PMax Hair Serums (3.06x, $126K), Shopping Catchall (3.04x, $18K), Subscription PMax (2.85x, $74K, currently paused), Shampoo Kits (2.69x, $124K), Memorial Day PMax (2.64x, $17K), Shopping USA (2.39x, $467K), Scalp Duo (2.31x, $64K).
Sorted by spend within each group. Yellow = NCAC campaigns. Blue = Top-of-Funnel campaigns. Red highlight = Primary ROAS below 1.0x.
| # | Campaign | Status | Active Since | YTD Spend | Primary Conv | Primary Rev | Primary ROAS | New Cust | NCAC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CORE CAMPAIGNS | |||||||||
| 1 | Branded Search USA | Enabled | Jan 1 | $901,898 | 38,265 | $3,700,788 | 4.10x | 14,767 | $61 |
| 2 | Shopping USA | Enabled | Jan 1 | $466,951 | 13,030 | $1,113,815 | 2.39x | 7,013 | $67 |
| 3 | Nonbranded Shopping USA | Paused | Jan 1 | $153,769 | 3,152 | $179,835 | 1.17x | 2,778 | $55 |
| 4 | PMax | Hair Serums | Enabled | Jan 1 | $125,686 | 3,267 | $384,303 | 3.06x | 857 | $147 |
| 5 | Pmax - Shampoo Conditioner Kits | Enabled | Jan 1 | $123,836 | 3,246 | $333,077 | 2.69x | 996 | $124 |
| 6 | Subscription | PMax | Paused | Jan 1 | $73,595 | 2,365 | $210,059 | 2.85x | - | - |
| 7 | Scalp Duo | PMax | New Product | Enabled | Jul 22 | $64,246 | 1,766 | $148,682 | 2.31x | 361 | $178 |
| 8 | Non-Brand Search USA | Enabled | Jan 1 | $63,961 | 489 | $42,292 | 0.66x | 366 | $175 |
| 9 | US_Mid_C_Combo_Search-NB-Exact | Paused | Jan 1 | $49,731 | 612 | $53,714 | 1.08x | 383 | $130 |
| 10 | Male | Hair Serum | PMax | Enabled | Jan 1 | $44,781 | 1,044 | $97,143 | 2.17x | 195 | $230 |
| 11 | PMax | Style Wand | Enabled | Jan 1 | $35,831 | 739 | $76,782 | 2.14x | 212 | $169 |
| 12 | US_Mid_C_Combo_Search-NB-DSA | Paused | Jan 1 | $34,036 | 338 | $23,241 | 0.68x | 199 | $171 |
| 13 | Pmax - Everything Else - USA | Enabled | Jan 1 | $28,553 | 464 | $56,617 | 1.98x | 299 | $96 |
| 14 | US_Mid_C_Hair_Search-NB-Broad | Paused | Jan 1 | $28,546 | 194 | $17,822 | 0.62x | 109 | $262 |
| 15 | PMax | Lash Serum | Enabled | Jan 1 | $28,024 | 905 | $79,577 | 2.84x | 232 | $121 |
| 16 | Shopping Catchall USA (t) | Enabled | Jan 1 | $18,145 | 716 | $55,227 | 3.04x | 410 | $44 |
| 17 | Memorial Day Sale 2026 | PMax | Paused | May 1 | $17,320 | 475 | $45,684 | 2.64x | 169 | $103 |
| 18 | US_Mid_C_Hair_Shopping-NB-Shampoo | Paused | Jan 1 | $11,299 | 73 | $6,366 | 0.56x | 42 | $269 |
| 19 | US_Mid_C_LashBrow_Search-NB-Lash | Paused | Jan 1 | $10,628 | 83 | $5,944 | 0.56x | 29 | $367 |
| 20 | US_Lower_C_Combo_Search-BR | Enabled | Jan 1 | $10,546 | 548 | $45,076 | 4.27x | 231 | $46 |
| 21 | Hydr8 Oil | PMax | Enabled | Jul 13 | $10,146 | 286 | $27,158 | 2.68x | 104 | $98 |
| 22 | US_Mid_C_Hair_Shopping-NB-Serum | Paused | Jan 1 | $7,437 | 39 | $3,967 | 0.53x | 19 | $391 |
| 23 | PMax | Spring Sale | Paused | Mar 1 | $5,725 | 201 | $20,769 | 3.63x | 46 | $124 |
| 24 | US_Lower_C_Combo_Search-BR_2 | Paused | Jan 1 | $4,833 | 31 | $2,458 | 0.51x | 13 | $372 |
| 25 | Pmax - Everything Else - (t) | Enabled | Jan 1 | $3,711 | 61 | $8,666 | 2.34x | 22 | $169 |
| 26 | NB Shopping Spring Sale 2026 | Paused | Mar 1 | $2,319 | 50 | $3,754 | 1.62x | 36 | $64 |
| 27 | Pmax - Scalp - USA | Paused | Jan 1 | $1,880 | 38 | $4,656 | 2.48x | 10 | $188 |
| 28 | Remarketing | PMax | Returning | Paused | Jan 1 | $1,179 | 46 | $3,760 | 3.19x | 2 | $589 |
| NCAC (NEW CUSTOMER ACQUISITION) CAMPAIGNS | |||||||||
| 29 | Shopping USA | NCAC | Enabled | Aug 14 | $85,508 | 922 | $74,689 | 0.87x | 495 | $173 |
| 30 | Hair Quiz | PMax | NCAC | Enabled | Jul 3 | $58,310 | 1,082 | $90,633 | 1.55x | 417 | $140 |
| 31 | PMax | Hair Serums | NCAC | Enabled | Aug 20 | $34,190 | 335 | $30,585 | 0.89x | 247 | $138 |
| 32 | Pmax - Shampoo Conditioner | NCAC | Enabled | Aug 19 | $34,182 | 329 | $30,820 | 0.90x | 233 | $147 |
| 33 | Male | Hair Serum | PMax | NCAC | Paused | - | $0 | 0 | $0 | - | 0 | - |
| 34 | PMax | Lash Serum | NCAC | Paused | - | $0 | 0 | $0 | - | 0 | - |
| NCAC Subtotal | $212,190 | 2,668 | $226,727 | 1.07x | 1,392 | $153 | |||
| TOP-OF-FUNNEL / AWARENESS CAMPAIGNS | |||||||||
| 35 | Demand Generation | Enabled | May 13 | $147,755 | 1,411 | $120,889 | 0.82x | 82 | $1,802 |
| 36 | Video views - 2026-09-04 | Enabled | Sep 4 | $105,073 | 8 | $901 | 0.009x | 3 | $35,024 |
| 37 | Amazon Pilot | Demand Gen | Paused | Sep 4 | $64,968 | 35 | $2,492 | 0.04x | 11 | $5,906 |
| 38 | US_Upper_R_Combo_DG-RM-Remarketing | Paused | Jan 1 | $21,902 | 288 | $29,364 | 1.34x | 69 | $317 |
| 39 | US_Upper_R_Combo_DG-PR-Shorts | Paused | Jan 1 | $21,387 | 82 | $6,438 | 0.30x | 8 | $2,673 |
| 40 | US_Upper_C_Hair_DG-Seed-YouTube | Paused | Jan 1 | $2,509 | 13 | $1,072 | 0.43x | 3 | $836 |
| 41 | US_Upper_C_Hair_DG-Seed-Discover | Paused | Jan 1 | $2,509 | 10 | $1,159 | 0.46x | 2 | $1,254 |
| Top-of-Funnel Subtotal | $366,103 | 1,847 | $162,315 | 0.44x | 178 | $2,057 | |||
| GRAND TOTAL | $2,974,205 | 42,780 | $7,312,619 | 2.46x | 29,952 | $99 | |||
| Product | Non-NCAC Spend | Non-NCAC ROAS | NCAC Spend | NCAC ROAS | ROAS Gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shopping USA | $466,951 | 2.39x | $85,508 | 0.87x | -1.52x |
| Hair Serums PMax | $125,686 | 3.06x | $34,190 | 0.89x | -2.17x |
| Shampoo Kits PMax | $123,836 | 2.69x | $34,182 | 0.90x | -1.79x |
| Hair Quiz PMax | No non-NCAC counterpart | $58,310 | 1.55x | - | |
| Campaign | Spend | New Customers | NCAC | Primary ROAS |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shopping Catchall USA (t) | $18,145 | 410 | $44 | 3.04x |
| US_Lower_C_Combo_Search-BR | $10,546 | 231 | $46 | 4.27x |
| Nonbranded Shopping USA | $153,769 | 2,778 | $55 | 1.17x |
| Branded Search USA | $901,898 | 14,767 | $61 | 4.10x |
| NB Shopping Spring Sale | $2,319 | 36 | $64 | 1.62x |
| Shopping USA | $466,951 | 7,013 | $67 | 2.39x |
| Campaign | Spend | New Customers | NCAC | Primary ROAS |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Video views - 2026-09-04 | $105,073 | 3 | $35,024 | 0.009x |
| Amazon Pilot | Demand Gen | $64,968 | 11 | $5,906 | 0.04x |
| US_Upper_R_Combo_DG-PR-Shorts | $21,387 | 8 | $2,673 | 0.30x |
| Demand Generation | $147,755 | 82 | $1,802 | 0.82x |
| US_Upper_C_Hair_DG-Seed-Discover | $2,509 | 2 | $1,254 | 0.46x |
These campaigns are spending more than they generate in primary conversion revenue.
| Campaign | Status | YTD Spend | Primary Rev | ROAS | Loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Demand Generation | Enabled | $147,755 | $120,889 | 0.82x | -$26,866 |
| Video views - 2026-09-04 | Enabled | $105,073 | $901 | 0.009x | -$104,172 |
| Shopping USA | NCAC | Enabled | $85,508 | $74,689 | 0.87x | -$10,819 |
| Amazon Pilot | Demand Gen | Paused | $64,968 | $2,492 | 0.04x | -$62,476 |
| Non-Brand Search USA | Enabled | $63,961 | $42,292 | 0.66x | -$21,669 |
| PMax | Hair Serums | NCAC | Enabled | $34,190 | $30,585 | 0.89x | -$3,605 |
| Pmax - Shampoo Conditioner | NCAC | Enabled | $34,182 | $30,820 | 0.90x | -$3,362 |
| US_Mid_C_Combo_Search-NB-DSA | Paused | $34,036 | $23,241 | 0.68x | -$10,795 |
| US_Mid_C_Hair_Search-NB-Broad | Paused | $28,546 | $17,822 | 0.62x | -$10,724 |
| US_Upper_R_Combo_DG-PR-Shorts | Paused | $21,387 | $6,438 | 0.30x | -$14,949 |
| US_Mid_C_Hair_Shopping-NB-Shampoo | Paused | $11,299 | $6,366 | 0.56x | -$4,933 |
| US_Mid_C_LashBrow_Search-NB-Lash | Paused | $10,628 | $5,944 | 0.56x | -$4,684 |
| US_Mid_C_Hair_Shopping-NB-Serum | Paused | $7,437 | $3,967 | 0.53x | -$3,470 |
| US_Lower_C_Combo_Search-BR_2 | Paused | $4,833 | $2,458 | 0.51x | -$2,375 |
| US_Upper_C_Hair_DG-Seed-YouTube | Paused | $2,509 | $1,072 | 0.43x | -$1,437 |
| US_Upper_C_Hair_DG-Seed-Discover | Paused | $2,509 | $1,159 | 0.46x | -$1,350 |
| Total Underperforming | $698,821 | $371,135 | 0.53x | -$327,686 |
1. Pause all 4 NCAC campaigns ($212K YTD, 0.87-1.55x ROAS)
2. Pause Video Views ($105K YTD, 0.009x ROAS)
3. Pause Non-Brand Search USA ($64K YTD, 0.66x ROAS)
4. Confirm Amazon Pilot stays off ($65K YTD, 0.04x ROAS)
Monthly savings: ~$45-50K/mo
1. Cut Demand Generation budget by 50-75% ($148K at 0.82x, only 82 new customers all year)
2. Tighten Demand Gen audience exclusions (mostly hitting returning customers)
Additional monthly savings: ~$8-12K/mo
Push freed budget into proven performers:
1. PMax Hair Serums (3.06x, $126K spend, room to scale)
2. Shampoo Kits PMax (2.69x, $124K spend)
3. Scalp Duo PMax (2.31x, $64K, newest product performer since Jul 22)
4. PMax Lash Serum (2.84x, $28K, significantly under-scaled)
5. Shopping USA (2.39x, $467K, still efficient at scale)
6. Consider reactivating Subscription PMax (2.85x before pause)